Have you ever wondered why a Playwright sometimes doesn't wait for elements as expected?
As an automation engineer, I've faced this issue many times. In this article, we'll explore Playwright's auto-waiting mechanism and provide practical solutions for handling timing issues to increase the stability of test executions.
Playwright is a powerful framework for test automation. Its ability to automatically wait for elements before interacting with them is a standout feature that helps to speed up scripting. However, this auto-waiting mechanism doesn't always work perfectly.
Sometimes, Playwright tries to interact with elements before they're ready. Other times, it returns incomplete lists of elements. Let's understand why this happens and how to address it.
Before we dive into problem-solving, let's get a clear picture of how Playwright's auto-waiting actually works. It's not as straightforward as you might think:
1. Locators are just instructions
When you create a locator in Playwright, it's not actively searching for anything yet. It's more like a set of instructions for later use.
2. Actions trigger the search
Playwright only starts looking for web elements when you perform an "action" on a locator. Think of actions like click(), fill(), etc.
3. Each action has its own checklist
Different actions in Playwright have different sets of "actionability checks" they perform before executing.
Let's break down these actionability checks:
-
Visible: Is the element actually visible on the page?
-
Stable: Has the element stopped moving around?
-
Receives Events: Can the element respond to user interactions?
-
Enabled: Is the element not disabled?
-
Editable: For input elements, can we actually type into it?
Different actions require different checks. For instance, click() needs the element to pass checks like "Visible", "Stable", "Receives Events" and "Enabled", while selectText() only cares if the element is visible.
So, if Playwright has this smart auto-waiting system, why does it sometimes fails? The catch is that not all Playwright methods trigger this mechanism. Two common ones are all() and allTextContents().
These methods execute immediately when called, without waiting for any actionability checks. If your page isn't fully loaded when these methods run, you might end up with empty or partial results. It's like trying to read a book before all the pages have been printed!
When auto-waiting falls short, it's time to take matters into your own hands. Playwright offers a toolkit of dynamic waiting methods to ensure your elements are truly ready:
-
await page.waitForEvent(): Perfect for waiting on specific page events.
-
await page.waitForFunction(): Ideal for custom waiting conditions, when your function return result.
-
await page.waitForLoadState(): Ensures the page has reached a certain load state, such as "networkidle"
-
await page.waitForRequest(): Waits for a specific network request to be initiated.
-
await page.waitForResponse(): Waits for a specific network response to be received.
-
await page.waitForSelector(): Waits for a specific element to appear in the DOM.
-
await page.waitForURL(): Waits for the page URL to match a certain pattern.
-
waitFor(): Chained as an "action" command for a specific locator to be ready
All these methods are dynamic forms of waits. Playwright will wait for the expected condition up to the timeout. How to configure timeouts and deal with the most common timeout errors, check the earlier
blog post.
When working with web applications, you often need to extract data from table rows. This can be tricky because tables may load in different ways. Sometimes, you might find that Playwright tries to interact with table rows before they're fully loaded, resulting in incomplete or empty data.
There are two common scenarios we need to consider:
1. Tables that load all rows at once
2. Tables where rows are populated dynamically via API calls
Let's look at how to handle each of these cases:
For tables that load all at once:
Example:
In this case, we wait for the entire table to be present in the DOM before trying to access its rows. This works well for static tables or those that load quickly.
For tables with dynamically loaded data:
Example:
Here, we're waiting for the API response that populates the table. This ensures that the data is actually loaded before we try to access it. It's particularly useful for tables that fetch data asynchronously.
By using these approaches, you can ensure that your table rows are fully loaded and available before you attempt to extract or interact with them.
Another common scenario is when you need to extract a list of text values, such as items in a dropdown menu or a list of menu items. The allTextContents() method is typically used for this, but it can sometimes return incomplete results if the list isn't fully loaded.
Here are three strategies to handle this situation:
Use locator assertions:
Example:
This approach uses a locator assertion to wait for and verify the presence of expected text before extracting all text contents. Locator assertions have automatic waiting built-in, ensuring the text is available before proceeding.
To learn more about Locator Assertions and Generic Assertions, check out our
blog post.Wait for the API that populates the list:
Example:
If your list is populated by an API call, waiting for that specific response ensures the data is loaded before you try to extract it.
Wait for a stable parent element:
Example:
If you have a stable element that's loaded along with the list (like a <ul> tag), you can wait for this element to be present before extracting the text contents.
These strategies help ensure that when you use allTextContents(), you're working with a fully loaded list of values.
The core principle to remember when dealing with Playwright's waiting behavior is this: when you use Playwright action commands that don't have an auto-waiting mechanism, you need to handle the waiting yourself.
This means using one of the dynamic wait methods before the step with the action command. By doing this, you ensure that when the action command is executed, your application is loaded to the right state, and the list of text or web elements is available for you to work with.
Remember, different elements and scenarios may require different waiting strategies. It's important to understand your application's behavior and choose the most appropriate waiting method for each situation.
By implementing these waiting strategies effectively, you'll create more robust and reliable Playwright tests that can handle the complexities of modern web applications.
